If farmers have greater choice to sell to whoever & wherever! Why still Farmers are protesting?

ByKarthik Kumar D Kon9th Feb 2021, 2022-12-16T12:00:00+05:30
Read
Pause
Resume
Stop
If farmers have greater choice to sell to whoever & wherever! Why still Farmers are protesting?

The Rajya Sabha passed two out of the three Bills being referred to as the Farm Bills. These two Bills are the Farmers Produce Trade and Commerce (Promotion and Facilitation) Bill, 2020, and the Farmers (Empowerment and Protection) Agreement on Price Assurance and Farm Services Bill, 2020. The Lok Sabha had already passed these Bills. There was some ruckus in the Rajya Sabha where the Bill was passed through a voice vote.

If farmers have greater choice to sell to whoever & wherever, if there is contract farming with safeguards to give assured price & improve quality, if trading & storage restrictions are removed [link] Why still Farmers are protesting? Let's take a look.

1. The farmers of Punjab, Haryana & Western Uttar Pradesh, are the ones primarily protesting. Why?

  • Government procurement infrastructure in these areas is very good, This is because the Green Revolution of the 1960s started here.
  • Government offered procurement through Food Corporation of India (FCI) & a minimum support price (MSP) to farmers, before every agriculture season.
  • The system has evolved & the Government sets an MSP on 23 agricultural crops, it has bought some pulses and oilseeds as well.
  • The fear among farmers is that next step in agriculture reform process might be doing away of government procurement process as well as MSP. This is going to primarily hurt farmers from Punjab & Haryana, who benefit tremendously from this.

2. The farmers who benefit from government procurement process & MSP are medium & large farmers [link] - published by Commission for Agricultural Costs & Prices 2020-21.

  • Hence, it's the bigger farmers who are protesting.
  • Government have assured that there are no plans to do away with government procurement or MSP policy, But protestors don't seem to be buying these assurances.

3. Why big farmers not buying the government's assurances? The answer lies in the fact that it might be natural that next step in the process of reforming agriculture is reforming government procurement & MSP policy.

4. The MSP policy has led to excess production & excess procurement of rice & wheat by government over the years. As of Sep 2020, FCI had 700.27 lakh tonnes of rice & wheat. As per stocking norms FCI needs to have 411.2 lakh tonnes as of July. If they are incentivised to grow something, with a regular buyer available (Government), they are bound to do that.

5. Other big fear among farmers, those representing them & many economists, is that large corporates will take over contract farming. And their might be increase in cost of production such as human labour, machinery, seeds, fertilisers, fuel, etc.

To conclude, Government procurement & MSP where introduced in a time when India didn't produce enough food grains to feed itself. And with new Farm Laws, honestly big farmers can still do business, where as small farmers (2-5 acres) & marginal farmers (5-10 acres) will be benefited a lot.

1,600OFF
Xtore Beautiful Finish Uniquely Hand Crafted Home Dcor African Tribal Women Art Piece - (Set of 3, Multicolour), Resin

Xtore Beautiful Finish Uniquely Hand Crafted Home Dcor African Tribal Women Art Piece - (Set of 3, Multicolour), Resin

899 2,499
These uniquely hand crafted and painted resin black African tribal lady figure make an excellent compliment to any home/office decor. It makes a great display for culture/tradition appreciation events and a perfect gift for your loved ones. Unique and Rare - Hand Painted and Hand Crafted.
Home & Decor
13,000OFF
OnePlus 108 cm (43 inches) Y Series 4K Ultra HD Smart Android LED TV 43Y1S Pro (Black)

OnePlus 108 cm (43 inches) Y Series 4K Ultra HD Smart Android LED TV 43Y1S Pro (Black)

26,999 39,999
Resolution : 4K Ultra HD (3840x2160) | Refresh Rate : 60 Hertz. Connectivity: 3 HDMI ports to connect set top box, Blu Ray players, gaming console | 2 USB ports to connect hard drives and other USB devices | Dual-band Wi-Fi Sound : 24 Watts Output | Dolby Audio | Dolby Atmos Decoding. Smart TV features: Android TV | OnePlus Connect Ecosystem| Google Assistant | Chromecast, Miracast, DLNA | Auto Low Latency Mode | Supported Apps : Netflix, Youtube, Prime Video, Hotstar, SonyLiv, Hungama, JioCinema, Zee5, Eros Now, Oxygen Play.
Televisions
7,000OFF
OnePlus 80 cm (32 inches) Y Series HD Ready LED Smart Android TV 32Y1 (Black)

OnePlus 80 cm (32 inches) Y Series HD Ready LED Smart Android TV 32Y1 (Black)

12,999 19,999
Resolution: HD Ready (1366x768) | Refresh Rate: 60 hertz. Connectivity: 2 HDMI ports to connect set top box, Blu Ray players, gaming console | 2 USB ports to connect hard drives and other USB devices, Dimensions(TV With Stand) - 71.3cm x 20cm x 46.9cm | VESA Hole Pitch - 20cm x 20cm. Sound : 20 Watts Output | Dolby Audio. Smart TV Features: Android TV 9.0 | OnePlus Connect | Google Assistant | Play Store | Chromecast | Shared Album | Supported Apps : Netflix, YouTube, Prime video | Content Calendar | OxygenPlay. Display : LED Panel | Noise Reduction | Colour Space Mapping |Dynamic Contrast | Anti-Aliasing | DCI-P3 93% colour gamut | Gamma Engine | Design: Bezel-less | Screen/Body Ratio = 91.4%. Warranty Information: 1 year comprehensive warranty and additional 1 year on panel provided by the manufacturer from date of purchase.
Televisions

Related Articles

1,031OFF
eCraftIndia Ganesh Deepak with Bell Brass Wall Hanging (11 cm x 8 cm x 24 cm, Brown)

eCraftIndia Ganesh Deepak with Bell Brass Wall Hanging (11 cm x 8 cm x 24 cm, Brown)

968 1,999
1 Brass Ganeshs wall hanging Deepak with bell and Dancing Ganesha. Don't wash, use dry/wet cotton cloth to remove dirt.
Home & Decor

Recent Articles

Recent Quick Read

Recent Great People

32,991OFF
Hisense 139 cm (55 inches) Tornado 2.0 Series 4K Ultra HD Smart LED Google TV 55A7H (Silver)

Hisense 139 cm (55 inches) Tornado 2.0 Series 4K Ultra HD Smart LED Google TV 55A7H (Silver)

36,999 69,990
Resolution : 4K Ultra HD (3840x2160) | Refresh Rate : 60 Hertz | 178 Degree wide viewing angle. Connectivity: 3 HDMI ports to connect set top box, Blu Ray players, gaming console (HDMI 1 eARC supported) | 2 USB ports to connect hard drives and other USB devices | Dual-band Wi-Fi | Bluetooth 5.1. Sound : 102 Watts Output | JBL 6 Speakers System | Dolby Atmos for remarkable sound quality. Smart TV features: Google TV with Watchlist | Google Play Store | Google Assistant | Chromecast, Miracast, DLNA, Airplay | Auto Low Latency Mode for VRR | Supported Apps : Netflix, Youtube, Prime Video, Hotstar, SonyLiv, Hungama, JioCinema, Zee5, Eros Now. Display :10 bit Panel | Bezel-less Floating Display Design | ALLM | Decoding of Dolby Vision, HDR10, HLG | 1 Billion Colours | MEMC. Warranty Information: 2 Year Comprehensive Warranty on product provided by Hisense from date of purchase.. Installation: For requesting installation/wall mounting/demo of this product once delivered, please directly call Hisense Support for assistance (Please visit Hisense Website for Toll Free Numbers) and provide product's model name and seller's details mentioned on your invoice. The service center will allot you a convenient slot for the service. Easy Returns: This product is eligible for replacement within 10 days of delivery in case of any product defects, damage or features not matching the description.
Televisions
26,991OFF
Hisense 139 cm (55 inches) Bezelless Series 4K Ultra HD Smart LED Google TV 55A6H (Black)

Hisense 139 cm (55 inches) Bezelless Series 4K Ultra HD Smart LED Google TV 55A6H (Black)

32,999 59,990
Resolution : 4K Ultra HD (3840x2160) | Refresh Rate : 60 Hertz | 178 Degree wide viewing angle. Connectivity: 3 HDMI ports to connect set top box, Blu Ray players, gaming console | 2 USB ports to connect hard drives and other USB devices | Dual-band Wi-Fi | Bluetooth 5.1. Sound : 24 Watts Output | Dolby Atmos | Dolby Digital. Smart TV features: Google TV | Watchlist | Google Assistant | Far Field Vioce Control | Chromecast, Miracast, DLNA | Auto Low Latency Mode for VRR | Supported Apps : Netflix, Youtube, Prime Video, Hotstar, SonyLiv, Hungama, JioCinema, Zee5, Eros Now. Display :10 bit Panel | Bezel-less Floating Display Design | ALLM | Decoding of Dolby Vision, HDR10, HLG | 1 Billion Colours | MEMC.
Televisions
350OFF
Amazon Brand - Solimo Slim Stainless Steel Water Bottle, Set of 3, 1 L Each

Amazon Brand - Solimo Slim Stainless Steel Water Bottle, Set of 3, 1 L Each

649 999
Stainless Steel water bottle set for home and office use. Made using high quality stainless steel for added durability and long life. Made from 100% food grade materials to be safe for everyday usage. Features a spill-proof design; has a snug fitting lid for easy usage and prevention of leaks. Ergonomic design for comfortable grip and rust free body. Ideal for storing water, iced tea, juices, shakes and more. Dimensions: L x W x H: 7.3 x 7.3 x 26 cm. Package Contents:- Solimo Stainless Steel Water Bottle Set of 3, Weight: 200 gm each, Colour: Silver, Capacity: 1 litre each.
Kitchen & Dining
1,272OFF
Bajaj Rex 500W Mixer Grinder, Purple

Bajaj Rex 500W Mixer Grinder, Purple

2,278 3,550
Wattage : 500 W, Voltage: 230V~50 Hz: Revolution: 20,000 RPM. Powerful 500W Titan Motor with Radio Knob: Easy selection of Speed. 2-in-1 Blade: The dry grinding jar can be used for dry and chutney grinding both. Product warranty by Bajaj - 2 Years. T&C Applied. Pulse Mode: Used for mixing and grinding without stopping your mixie. Perfect to mince chicken , get bread crumps, small puree and making lump free gravies.
Kitchen Appliances
We Need Your Consent
By clicking “Accept Cookies”, you agree to the storing of cookies on your device to enhance your site navigation experience.
I Accept Cookies